Better News Network
Politics / Article

Wisconsin judge accused of helping man evade immigration agents files to dismiss charges

3 minute read

Published: Thursday, May 15, 2025 at 2:18 am

Wisconsin Judge Fights Charges of Aiding Immigration Evasion, Citing Immunity

A Wisconsin judge, Hannah Dugan, is fighting back against federal charges that she helped a man evade U.S. immigration agents. Dugan, a Milwaukee County Circuit Judge, filed a motion Wednesday to dismiss the case, arguing that she is protected by judicial immunity.

The charges stem from an incident in April where Dugan allegedly assisted Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, who was in the country illegally after being deported, in avoiding arrest at her courthouse. Prosecutors claim Dugan became angry at the presence of immigration agents and, after discussing the arrest warrant, led them away from the courtroom. She then allegedly directed Flores-Ruiz and his attorney out a back door, allowing them to evade the agents, who ultimately apprehended Flores-Ruiz after a foot chase.

Dugan's attorneys argue that her actions were part of her official duties as a judge, specifically directing movement within the courtroom. They cite the Supreme Court's ruling on presidential immunity, suggesting that she is entitled to similar protection. The motion emphasizes that judicial immunity is an absolute bar to prosecution, not a defense to be decided later.

Federal prosecutors charged Dugan with obstruction and concealing an individual to prevent arrest, charges that could carry a six-year prison sentence. Dugan, who has been suspended from the bench by the state Supreme Court, is expected to plead not guilty. Her case has drawn comparisons to a similar case during the Trump administration involving a Massachusetts judge, which was ultimately dismissed. Dugan's motion also accuses the federal government of violating Wisconsin's sovereignty by interfering with state court proceedings. The judge overseeing the case is Lynn Adelman, a former Democratic state senator appointed to the bench by Bill Clinton.

BNN's Perspective: This case highlights the complex interplay between federal immigration enforcement and the role of state courts. While the allegations against Judge Dugan are serious, the argument for judicial immunity raises important questions about the balance of power and the potential for political motivations in such prosecutions. It's crucial that the legal process is followed meticulously to ensure fairness and uphold the integrity of the judiciary.

Keywords: Wisconsin judge, Hannah Dugan, immigration, evasion, judicial immunity, obstruction, concealing, federal charges, Lynn Adelman, Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, courthouse, arrest, Trump administration, Democrats, state court, Milwaukee County, Supreme Court, legal battle, dismissal motion.

Full Story