When generosity becomes a financial burden

Published: Tuesday, December 23, 2025 at 6:12 pm

Generosity's Financial Fallout: A Family's Dilemma

A reader, identified as "NO MORE GIFTS," has written to Dear Abby seeking advice on a challenging family dynamic. The core issue revolves around the reader's mother, a retired individual living on a fixed income, who consistently overspends on gifts for family members. This generosity, however, is unsustainable.

The mother showers the reader and their children with expensive presents, particularly during holidays. Shortly after, she requests financial assistance from the reader, citing a lack of funds. The reader has attempted to mitigate the situation by returning the gifts and saving the money for their mother's needs. This strategy has led to conflict, with the mother becoming angry upon discovering the practice.

Despite the financial strain, the mother is unwilling to reduce her gift-giving habits. She views her spending on gifts and her need for financial support as separate matters. The reader feels obligated to provide financial assistance, recognizing that the mother's limited income could jeopardize her ability to cover essential expenses like rent and groceries.

The reader's primary concern is how to persuade the mother to adjust her spending habits. They desire a shift in the mother's perspective, hoping she will prioritize financial stability over extravagant gift-giving. The reader would prefer to avoid the cycle of receiving gifts and subsequently providing financial support.

Dear Abby's response suggests that the mother's behavior is unlikely to change. The advice centers on accepting the situation and continuing to manage the financial implications. The recommendation also includes suggesting the mother seek part-time employment to increase her disposable income.

BNN's Perspective: This situation highlights a common challenge faced by many families: the intersection of generosity, financial constraints, and familial obligations. While the mother's intentions are undoubtedly well-meaning, her actions create a financial burden on her family. Finding a balance between expressing love and maintaining financial stability is crucial. The reader's dilemma underscores the importance of open communication and realistic expectations within families, especially when dealing with fixed incomes and changing life circumstances.

Keywords: gifts, financial burden, family, retirement, spending, income, generosity, Dear Abby, advice, money, holidays, presents, conflict, support, obligations

Full Story