The Lost Magic Of Manufacturing Employment Never Really Was

Published: Tuesday, May 27, 2025 at 5:17 pm

The Myth of the "Good Ol' Days" of Manufacturing: Why Nostalgia Doesn't Equal Economic Reality

The article delves into the often-romanticized past of manufacturing jobs in America, particularly in the Rust Belt, and challenges the notion that these were universally "good ol' days." While acknowledging the decline in manufacturing employment, the piece argues that this shift hasn't necessarily harmed the overall economy. In fact, the economy has grown, with unemployment falling significantly since 1979.

The article highlights that the high wages associated with manufacturing in certain eras and locations, like the Great Lakes region, were often a result of specific circumstances. These included access to resources (like iron ore and coal), transportation networks, and a limited labor pool. Unionization, particularly in the auto industry, also played a role in driving up wages. However, this wasn't a universal experience across all manufacturing sectors. Industries like apparel, with more competition and less capital-intensive production, saw wages fluctuate and jobs shift to lower-cost regions.

The decline of Rust Belt manufacturing is attributed to factors like foreign competition (e.g., Japanese car manufacturers), which offered consumers better value. The article also points out that the Big Three automakers' union contracts, while offering high wages, put them at a disadvantage.

The article concludes by noting that the willingness of people to move for jobs has decreased, and the economy has shifted towards service-oriented industries. The author suggests that focusing on customer satisfaction, production efficiency, and long-term employment strategies is more beneficial than trying to revive a dying wave of manufacturing jobs.

BNN's Perspective: While the article presents a compelling argument against romanticizing the past, it's important to acknowledge the real impact the decline of manufacturing had on communities. The loss of these jobs created significant economic hardship for many families. While the overall economy has grown, it's crucial to consider policies that support workers in transitioning to new industries and address the social and economic challenges faced by communities affected by these shifts.

Keywords: manufacturing jobs, Rust Belt, economy, unemployment, wages, productivity, unionization, foreign competition, automobile industry, economic development, labor mobility, production efficiency, customer satisfaction, economic history, American manufacturing, job market

Full Story