The Hollowness of Growth as an Objective

Published: Wednesday, October 8, 2025 at 3:08 pm

Progressives Face Accusations of Embracing "Degrowth"

A recent article, originally published in *The Sling*, highlights a recurring criticism leveled against progressive political thought: the accusation of embracing "degrowth." This framework, which has existed for some time, is now being discussed more frequently.

The commentary community, including figures like Matt Yglesias and Alex Trembath, along with the podcast "Everyone Gets Pie," have frequently used this critique. The central argument appears to be that certain progressive policies implicitly or explicitly advocate for a reduction in economic activity. This is often framed as a rejection of traditional economic growth as a primary objective.

The article suggests that the concept of degrowth is gaining traction within certain progressive circles. The core of the debate seems to revolve around the prioritization of economic growth versus other societal goals. Critics of degrowth often argue that it would lead to economic hardship and stagnation. Proponents, on the other hand, may view it as a necessary step towards environmental sustainability or a more equitable distribution of resources.

The article implies that the debate is ongoing and that the implications of degrowth are complex and far-reaching. The focus is on the perceived tension between progressive ideals and the traditional pursuit of economic expansion. The article suggests that the debate is ongoing and that the implications of degrowth are complex and far-reaching.

BNN's Perspective:

The debate surrounding degrowth highlights a fundamental tension in modern political discourse. While economic growth has historically been seen as a key indicator of societal progress, its environmental and social costs are increasingly scrutinized. Finding a balance between economic prosperity, environmental sustainability, and social equity is a challenge that requires careful consideration of all perspectives. The accusations of degrowth should be taken seriously, as they reflect a growing concern about the long-term viability of our current economic model.

Keywords: degrowth, progressives, economic growth, environmental sustainability, social equity, political discourse, economic policy, Matt Yglesias, Alex Trembath, Everyone Gets Pie

Full Story