Saints could be barreling toward Arch Manning derby after Derek Carr retirement shocker

Published: Saturday, May 10, 2025 at 5:39 pm

Saints' QB Future Uncertain After Carr Retirement, Arch Manning Derby Looms

The New Orleans Saints are facing a quarterback conundrum following the unexpected retirement of Derek Carr. This leaves the team with a young, unproven trio of quarterbacks – Tyler Shough, Spencer Rattler, and Jake Haener – vying for the starting role. With Rattler and Haener's combined 0-7 record as starters, the Saints' quarterback situation is far from settled.

The situation could become even more intriguing. If Shough struggles, the Saints could find themselves in a position to compete for the top pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. This scenario could set the stage for a potential "Arch Manning derby."

Arch Manning, the grandson of Saints legend Archie Manning and a New Orleans native, could be a prime target. The allure of playing for his hometown team, following in the footsteps of his grandfather and uncles Peyton and Eli Manning, could be a powerful draw. However, Manning is expected to spend at least four years in college, potentially pushing his draft eligibility to 2027.

Adding another layer of complexity is Saints offensive coordinator Doug Nussmeier. His son, Garrett Nussmeier, a quarterback for LSU, is also a highly-regarded prospect. Doug Nussmeier's potential influence on the Saints' quarterback decision could add a fascinating dynamic to the team's future. Garrett Nussmeier, who led the SEC in completions and attempts last season, opted to return to LSU to further solidify his draft stock. The Saints' quarterback situation is now a complex mix of potential, hometown ties, and family connections, making the future of the position one of the most interesting storylines in the NFL.

Keywords: Saints, Derek Carr, retirement, quarterback, Arch Manning, Garrett Nussmeier, NFL Draft, Tyler Shough, Spencer Rattler, Jake Haener, Archie Manning, Doug Nussmeier, LSU, New Orleans, 2026 Draft, 2027 Draft, NFL, football

Full Story