Lucy Letbys Writings on Infant Deaths Might Support Her Innocence

Published: Monday, August 25, 2025 at 4:14 am

Lucy Letby Case: Handwritten Notes Raise Questions About Conviction

The case of Lucy Letby, convicted of murdering seven infants and attempting to murder seven others, is under scrutiny. A key piece of evidence presented by the prosecution was a collection of handwritten notes found at Letby's home. These notes contained phrases like "I AM EVIL. I DID THIS," which the prosecution argued were admissions of guilt.

However, a psychologist with over two decades of experience in criminal behavior suggests a different interpretation. The psychologist argues that these notes, written during a period of extreme stress and under the advice of her GP and hospital staff, could be a manifestation of trauma and anguish rather than a confession. The psychologist highlights that such "stream-of-consciousness" writing is a common therapeutic tool used to help individuals externalize and process difficult emotions. The notes, filled with expressions of despair and fear, may reflect a mind struggling with the accusations and the unfolding events.

The defense's failure to provide a comprehensive alternative explanation for the notes, coupled with the prosecution's emphasis on them as evidence of guilt, raises questions about the conviction. The psychologist emphasizes that the notes' content is inconsistent with the prosecution's portrayal of Letby as a cold-blooded killer.

The Criminal Cases Review Commission is now reviewing the convictions, and the interpretation of these notes may play a crucial role in the process.

BNN's Perspective: While the evidence against Letby was substantial, the interpretation of the handwritten notes warrants further consideration. The possibility that these notes reflect a state of extreme distress, rather than a direct admission of guilt, highlights the complexities of this case and the importance of a thorough examination of all evidence.

Keywords: Lucy Letby, infant deaths, handwritten notes, conviction, prosecution, defense, psychologist, trauma, stream-of-consciousness, Criminal Cases Review Commission, guilt, innocence, criminal behavior, therapy, evidence, legal, court case.

Full Story