Long-Running Legal Battle Over Free Speech in Schools May Be Settled by Supreme Court

Published: Saturday, May 10, 2025 at 10:00 am

The Supreme Court is considering whether to hear a significant free speech case involving a Massachusetts middle schooler, Liam Morrison. The case centers around a T-shirt Morrison wore to school in March 2023 that stated "There Are Only Two Genders." School officials deemed the shirt a violation of the dress code, citing its potential to target LGBTQ+ students. Morrison's parents, supported by legal counsel, argued the shirt expressed a general belief and didn't constitute hate speech, asserting his right to free expression.

The school district, however, maintained the shirt created a potentially hostile environment for LGBTQ+ students, citing concerns about student well-being and the unique environment of a school setting. The district court initially sided with the school, a decision upheld by the First Circuit Court of Appeals. The appeals court emphasized that free speech rights are not as broad in schools as in the wider community, giving school officials latitude in regulating student expression.

The case has drawn significant attention, with opposing amicus briefs filed by various organizations. The ACLU of Massachusetts and others support the school's position, while attorneys general from 18 states and conservative groups back Morrison's free speech claim. The Supreme Court's decision to hear the case could have far-reaching implications for student free speech rights and the authority of schools to regulate expression in the classroom.

BNN's Perspective: This case highlights the complex balance between protecting free speech and fostering an inclusive school environment. While schools have a responsibility to create a safe space for all students, restricting expression based on viewpoint can be problematic. The Supreme Court's decision will need to carefully consider the potential impact on both student well-being and the fundamental right to express one's beliefs.

Keywords: Supreme Court, free speech, Liam Morrison, Massachusetts, school dress code, LGBTQ+, gender identity, First Amendment, student rights, First Circuit Court of Appeals, hate speech, school environment, amicus brief, censorship, public schools, student expression, two genders, school officials, legal battle, constitutional rights

Full Story