Judge upholds Trumps authority to deport criminal migrants under Alien Enemies Act

Published: Wednesday, May 14, 2025 at 7:49 am

Judge Sides with Trump on Deporting Criminal Migrants, But with a Catch

A federal judge has ruled that the Trump administration can, in principle, use the Alien Enemies Act (AEA) to deport criminal illegal immigrants belonging to the Venezuelan Tren De Aragua gang. However, the judge also stated that the administration failed to provide adequate prior notice to those targeted for removal, potentially hindering the deportations. This ruling, delivered by US District Judge Stephanie Haines, a Trump appointee, marks a significant development in the ongoing legal battles surrounding immigration enforcement.

The 43-page decision, issued on Tuesday, specifically addresses Venezuelan aliens who are not naturalized citizens or lawful permanent residents, are 14 years or older, and have been designated as members of the Tren De Aragua gang, a group considered a Foreign Terrorist Organization. The judge's ruling acknowledges the President's authority to invoke the AEA in this context, but emphasizes the importance of due process.

This decision contrasts with a previous ruling by another judge, US District Court Judge Fernando Rodriguez Jr., also a Trump appointee, who stated that the AEA could not be used to expel alleged gang members. This highlights the complex legal landscape surrounding the use of the AEA, a rarely-used law dating back to 1798. The core question at the heart of these cases is whether the President can utilize the AEA to detain and remove Venezuelan aliens affiliated with the Tren de Aragua.

Judge Haines' ruling underscores the ongoing debate about the balance between national security concerns and the rights of immigrants. The judge's concluding remarks suggest that the ultimate decision on immigration policy rests with the elected officials and the public.

BNN's Perspective: This ruling underscores the complexities of immigration law and the challenges of balancing national security with due process. While the court's recognition of the President's authority to deport criminal aliens is understandable, the emphasis on providing adequate notice is crucial. It reflects a commitment to upholding fundamental rights, even in the context of enforcing immigration laws. The differing opinions among judges highlight the need for clear legal guidance and a consistent approach to these sensitive issues.

Keywords: Alien Enemies Act, AEA, Trump administration, deportation, criminal immigrants, Tren De Aragua, Venezuelan gang, illegal immigration, due process, Judge Stephanie Haines, federal court, immigration law, national security, executive order, foreign terrorist organization, legal challenges, US District Court, Fernando Rodriguez Jr.

Full Story