Judge says US must allow migrants a chance to challenge in court any deportations to Libya

Published: Thursday, May 8, 2025 at 2:55 am

**Judge Blocks US Deportations to Libya Without Court Challenge**

A federal judge has stepped in to prevent the US government from deporting migrants to Libya without allowing them to challenge the removals in court. US District Judge Brian E. Murphy, based in Massachusetts, ruled Wednesday that such deportations would violate a previous court order. This order mandates that migrants facing deportation to countries other than their homeland must first be given the opportunity to argue that their safety would be jeopardized.

The ruling comes after immigration attorneys reported that some migrants in detention were informed of plans to send them to Libya, a country with a well-documented history of human rights violations. Attorneys representing migrants from Vietnam detailed how their clients were pressured to sign documents agreeing to deportation to Libya, even being placed in solitary confinement when they refused. Some migrants were also reportedly told they would be deported to Saudi Arabia.

Judge Murphy's order requires the government to provide details about these alleged deportation plans. While Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem stated she couldn't confirm the reports, the judge's intervention highlights growing concerns about the Trump administration's deportation practices. The administration has previously deported individuals to countries like Panama, Costa Rica, and, controversially, Venezuelans to El Salvador.

The judge's ruling underscores the importance of due process and the potential for abuse when migrants are deported to countries where they are not citizens. The numbers involved in these specific cases may be relatively small, but the implications for human rights and legal protections are significant.

BNN's Perspective: This situation highlights the complex balancing act between enforcing immigration laws and upholding human rights. While the government has a responsibility to manage its borders, it's crucial to ensure that individuals facing deportation have a fair opportunity to argue their case, especially when facing potential danger in the destination country. This ruling is a necessary check on potential overreach and a reminder that due process must be a priority.

Keywords: US deportations, Libya, court order, Judge Brian E. Murphy, human rights violations, immigration attorneys, Department of Homeland Security, Kristi Noem, migrant detention, solitary confinement, due process, Trump administration, deportation practices, Saudi Arabia, El Salvador, migrant safety

Full Story