Glasgow's low emission zone legal challenge fails
Image source,
Getty Images
A last minute legal challenge against Glasgow's low emission zone has been thrown out by a judge.
The scheme to ban more polluting vehicles from the city centre will start at midnight.
Patons Accident Repair Centre took the case to the Court of Session in Edinburgh in a bid have it suspended ahead of further court action.
It accused Glasgow City Council of not consulting properly and putting businesses at risk.
But a judge at the Court of Session refused the motion and said the balance of convenience lay heavily in favour of the local authority and granted it expenses following the hearing.
After the ruling a council spokeswoman said the LEZ would come into force as planned.
Low emission zone rules 'could hit homeless'
The business which brought the case estimated it would lose a third of its business when it could no longer repair older vehicles.
Its workshop on Lister Street is about 500m (0.3 miles) inside the LEZ boundary in Townhead, an area with several car dealerships.
Four of those business previously joined Patons to propose a new boundary for the LEZ, but it was rejected by the council.
Company director William Paton told the Glasgow Times he did not think his business would last another two years within the low emission zone.
Image source,
Google
Image caption,
Patons Accident Repair Centre estimated it would lose a third of its business when it could no longer repair older vehicles
But the ruling was welcomed by Asthma + Lung Scotland, which described air pollution as a "public health emergency".
Joseph Carter, the charity's head, said: "It will mean a reduction in harmful air pollution for everyone.
"With one in five Scots developing a lung condition like asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in their lifetime, for them, this is a day to celebrate."
'Practical concerns'
The zone was conceived to tackle poor air quality, with many streets in Scotland regularly reaching harmful and illegal levels.
From midnight, when the new rules come into force, vehicles which do not meet emission standards will no longer be able to enter parts of the city centre.
Violations can lead to fines mounting to several hundreds of pounds per day.
While there are exemptions available for blue badge holders, motorbikes, mopeds and emergency vehicles, in general petrol cars made before 2005 and diesels built before September 2014 will not be allowed in the zone.
Scottish Conservative transport spokesman Graham Simpson said the legal challenges illustrated the way in which the "practical concerns of local businesses and communities have been ignored" by Glasgow's SNP and Green councillors.
"We all want to see a reduction in pollution and to meet environmental targets, but there is evidence that air quality is already meeting those standards, and that phase two will not result in further improvements," he said.
"Homeless charities and other groups, including St Andrew's First Aid, have said they would be prevented from operating effectively. There is an obvious danger to women and vulnerable groups, as well as shift workers, if late-night transport is unavailable."
Mr Simpson called on the council to urgently address the "flaws" in the scheme.
Wednesday, May 31, 2023 at 3:09 pm