Former Supreme Court Justice David H. Souter dies at 85

Published: Friday, May 9, 2025 at 1:21 pm

David Souter, Supreme Court Justice Known for Surprising Shifts, Dies at 85

Former Supreme Court Justice David H. Souter, a figure known for his quiet demeanor and surprising shifts in judicial philosophy, has passed away at the age of 85. Appointed by President George H.W. Bush in 1990, Souter was initially seen as a conservative pick. However, during his nearly two decades on the bench, he often sided with liberal justices, particularly on key issues like abortion rights, civil rights, and the separation of church and state.

Souter's most notable decisions included his crucial role in upholding *Roe v. Wade* in 1992, a move that surprised many of his Republican backers. He believed in upholding precedent, stating that overturning the landmark abortion ruling would "subvert the Court's legitimacy." He also voted to maintain the separation of church and state, including upholding a ban on school-sponsored prayer.

After retiring in 2009, Souter returned to his beloved New Hampshire, where he continued to serve on the First Circuit Court of Appeals. He was known for his privacy, shunning interviews and public statements throughout his career. His appointment was seen as a strategic move by President Bush, who sought to avoid a contentious confirmation battle. However, Souter's independent thinking and commitment to precedent ultimately led him to diverge from the conservative expectations.

Souter's legacy is complex. While he was not a staunch liberal, he consistently prioritized legal precedent and individual rights, often aligning with the court's more progressive voices. His career highlights the evolving nature of political ideologies and the importance of judicial independence.

BNN's Perspective: Justice Souter's story is a reminder that judging is not always predictable. His willingness to prioritize legal principles over political alignment, even when it meant disappointing those who appointed him, is a testament to his commitment to the law. His legacy serves as a valuable lesson in the importance of judicial independence and the potential for unexpected shifts in the political landscape.

Keywords: David Souter, Supreme Court, Justice, Abortion, Roe v. Wade, Republican, Conservative, Liberal, New Hampshire, Retirement, George H.W. Bush, Judicial Independence, Church-State Separation, Civil Rights, Obituary.

Full Story