DOJ Abandons Effort to Address Phoenixs Treatment of Homeless People

Published: Friday, May 23, 2025 at 7:30 pm

DOJ Abandons Phoenix Police Investigation, Raising Concerns for Homeless Rights

The Department of Justice (DOJ) has closed its investigation into the Phoenix Police Department, retracting findings of constitutional violations against homeless individuals. The probe, initiated in 2021, revealed a pattern of alleged abuses, including excessive force, illegal disposal of belongings, and disproportionate arrests of people experiencing homelessness. Despite these findings, the DOJ cited concerns about the potential for years of federal court micromanagement and high compliance costs as reasons for abandoning the effort to compel reforms through consent decrees.

The investigation found that homeless individuals accounted for 37% of Phoenix Police Department arrests between 2016 and 2022, despite representing less than 1% of the population. The DOJ's findings also highlighted instances of officers using excessive force and discriminatory practices. The DOJ's decision to end the investigation has drawn criticism from legal experts and advocates, who fear it could embolden cities to further marginalize the homeless population.

The city of Phoenix, in response, has stated its commitment to enhancing policy, training, and accountability measures. However, the DOJ's retraction comes amid ongoing legal battles and a Supreme Court decision that allows cities to arrest individuals for sleeping outside, even when shelter is unavailable. This has led to concerns that the homeless population will continue to face challenges.

BNN's Perspective:

While the DOJ's decision to end the investigation is disappointing, it's understandable given the potential for lengthy and costly federal oversight. The city of Phoenix's stated commitment to reform is a positive step, but it's crucial that these efforts are robustly implemented and independently monitored to ensure meaningful change. The focus should remain on addressing the root causes of homelessness and providing support, rather than criminalizing the unhoused.

Keywords: Phoenix Police, DOJ, Homelessness, Constitutional Violations, Excessive Force, Arrests, Encampments, Civil Rights, Consent Decree, Investigation, Phoenix, Arizona, Unhoused, Homeless, Police Brutality, Legal, Advocacy, Reform, Policy, Training, Accountability

Full Story