Did a Brooklyn couple kill a neighbors trees for a better view in Maine?

Published: Friday, September 12, 2025 at 5:14 pm

Maine Couple Faces Scrutiny Over Alleged Tree Poisoning

A Rockport, Maine couple, Stephen Antonson and Kathleen Hackett, are under scrutiny following allegations of poisoning trees on a neighbor's property to improve their harbor view. The couple, who purchased a summer home in 2017, repeatedly requested that their neighbor, Ruth Graham, remove trees blocking their view. Graham, a long-time resident and avid gardener, refused.

In 2020, Antonson and Hackett's sons sent Graham a note requesting a land purchase, which Graham declined. Shortly after, Graham's trees began to die. Investigations by the Maine Board of Pesticides Control revealed the trees had been poisoned with herbicides. The poisoning was limited to trees directly in line with the Antonson residence.

Antonson initially denied involvement but later agreed to a consent agreement, paying a $3,000 fine, the maximum penalty. Hackett was not named in the agreement. The case is ongoing, with the board rejecting the initial agreement and seeking an admission of guilt. Graham passed away in the winter of 2024.

The case highlights a growing trend of disputes over views in coastal areas. Similar incidents have occurred in other locations, including Camden, Kittery, Nantucket, and Martha's Vineyard, leading to legal settlements and fines. New legislation in Maine aims to increase penalties for unauthorized herbicide application.

BNN's Perspective: This case underscores the escalating tensions surrounding property values and the lengths some homeowners will go to enhance their views. While the financial penalty may seem insignificant, the ongoing legal battle and public scrutiny serve as a cautionary tale for those considering similar actions.

Keywords: Maine, Rockport, tree poisoning, view, property dispute, Stephen Antonson, Kathleen Hackett, Ruth Graham, herbicide, pesticide, legal, fines, coastal, real estate, neighbor, consent agreement

Full Story