Black Phone 2 a different but so-so sequel

Published: Friday, October 17, 2025 at 7:14 am

Black Phone 2: A Descent into Over-the-Top Horror

Director Scott Derrickson's sequel to the 2022 horror hit, *Black Phone*, has arrived, promising a return to the chilling world of the Grabber. The film, set four years after the original, sees the Grabber, played by Ethan Hawke, seeking revenge on Finney, now 17, for his defeat.

The film initially builds on the strengths of its predecessor, with effective cinematography, production design, and a haunting musical score. The story deviates from the original's formula, focusing on Finney's younger sister, Gwen, who experiences disturbing dreams connected to the family's past. The plot involves a snowy winter camp, where a long-dormant phone booth becomes a focal point.

The performances of the leads, particularly Madeleine McGraw as Gwen, are a highlight. However, the film struggles to maintain its initial momentum. The Grabber's character is reduced to a one-dimensional embodiment of evil. The climax, involving a supernatural battle, becomes overly frenzied.

While *Black Phone 2* offers some compelling elements, it ultimately loses its grip. The absence of a strong source material foundation, like the short story that inspired the first film, contributes to the sequel's shortcomings.

BNN's Perspective: *Black Phone 2* delivers a mixed bag. While the performances and initial setup are promising, the film ultimately succumbs to over-the-top horror tropes. The potential for a truly terrifying sequel is present, but the execution falls short, leaving viewers with a somewhat disappointing experience.

Keywords: Black Phone 2, Scott Derrickson, Ethan Hawke, horror movie, sequel, supernatural, Gwen, Finney, winter camp, Grabber, Madeleine McGraw, horror, movie review.

Full Story