Better Buy: Amazon vs. Target

Published: Friday, October 10, 2025 at 9:25 am

Amazon vs. Target: A Tale of Two Retail Giants

The retail sector has faced a challenging year, with both Amazon and Target experiencing significant stock fluctuations. While the broader market has seen gains, Amazon has underperformed, and Target has seen a substantial decline in its stock value. This divergence has led some investors to view these companies as potential value plays in a market at all-time highs.

Amazon, despite its dominance in e-commerce, is viewed by some as still being in its early stages of growth. The company's North America and international segments reported double-digit sales growth in the second quarter of 2025, with even more impressive operating income growth. Amazon's CEO emphasizes the vast potential for e-commerce expansion, noting that the majority of retail sales still occur in brick-and-mortar stores. The company is also investing heavily in areas like artificial intelligence and infrastructure, including its Project Kuiper satellite internet service and robotaxi services through Zoox. While its cloud computing unit, AWS, is growing at a slower pace than some competitors, it still saw substantial sales growth.

Target, on the other hand, is facing headwinds. The company's stock has declined, partly due to challenges in inventory management and adapting to changing consumer preferences. Target is focusing on enhancing its in-store experience to differentiate itself from value-focused competitors like Walmart and Costco. The company's stock is considered cheap, with a low price-to-earnings ratio and a compelling dividend. Despite the challenges, Target continues to generate significant free cash flow.

BNN's Perspective:

Both companies present unique investment opportunities. Amazon's growth potential in e-commerce and its investments in emerging technologies are attractive, but its valuation reflects that potential. Target offers a more value-oriented proposition, with a focus on dividends and a turnaround strategy. Investors should carefully consider their risk tolerance and investment goals when evaluating these two retail giants.

Keywords: Amazon, Target, retail stocks, e-commerce, AWS, cloud computing, stock value, investment, dividend, growth, market, inventory management, consumer behavior, Project Kuiper, Zoox, robotaxi, sales growth, operating income, free cash flow, price-to-earnings ratio

Full Story